Crypto-assets are high-risk and volatile. You could lose all the money you put in. Education only — not financial advice. Risk disclosure

News analysis ·

Celsius ex-CEO Mashinsky banned from crypto in New York deal

New York's attorney general secured up to $35 million and a lifetime industry ban from Alex Mashinsky. What Celsius got wrong, and the lesson for yield users.

Alex Mashinsky in a black T-shirt gesturing while speaking on a conference stage, with a white caption bar about his New York ban along the bottom
Photo: Web Summit / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0 (cropped)

New York Attorney General Letitia James has secured up to $35 million from Alex Mashinsky, the former CEO of crypto lender Celsius, along with a permanent ban from the securities, commodities and crypto industries, CoinDesk reported. This article looks at what went wrong at Celsius and what it teaches anyone who earns yield on deposits.

What happened

James announced the settlement on Friday. She had sued Mashinsky in 2023. The suit claimed he gave hundreds of thousands of people, over 26,000 of them in New York, a false picture of how safe their Celsius deposits were.

The money terms depend on conditions. Mashinsky must pay New York $25 million unless he hands $10 million of ill-gotten gains over to federal authorities. Another $10 million becomes due if he does not serve his full prison sentence. That sentence is 12 years in federal prison, after he admitted securities and commodities fraud. The CFTC, the US commodities regulator, had already barred him from commodities activity for life in June.

James was blunt about the case: "I will not allow scammers to use cryptocurrencies to prey on unsuspecting New Yorkers".

Why it went wrong

Celsius took customers' crypto and paid them yield on it. To pay that yield, a platform has to earn money with the deposits, for example by lending them out or trading. That means the deposits are no longer simply stored. They are being used, and they carry the risks of whatever the platform does with them.

According to James, Mashinsky pitched Celsius as a safer place than a bank. At the same time, she said, the firm put customer assets into risky strategies and hid the losses. A bank in many countries is supervised and its deposits may be insured up to a limit. A crypto yield platform usually offers no such protection, whatever its marketing says.

The weakness showed when customers wanted out. Celsius stopped all withdrawals in June 2022, and one month later it was in bankruptcy. Once a platform is in bankruptcy, depositors become creditors. They wait for a court process to decide how much they get back and when.

How the payouts have gone

Recovery has been partial and slow. When it came out of bankruptcy in 2024, Celsius planned payouts of roughly $3 billion, split between crypto and cash, using Coinbase and PayPal to make the payments. As of August, more than $3.4 billion had reached customers and creditors via the bankruptcy case, according to James. Those payments arrived years after the freeze, and during that time customers could not use their money.

What this means for your own accounts

The Celsius story is old, but the pattern still appears. Crypto yield is never certain, and you can lose some or all of what you deposit. These checks can help when a platform offers it.

  • Ask how the yield is earned. If the platform cannot explain clearly where the return comes from, treat that as a warning sign.
  • Read the terms on ownership. Some platforms say that deposited assets belong to them while deposited, which can put you in line with other creditors if they fail.
  • Be wary of any claim that a crypto platform is as safe as a bank or safer. Check whether deposits have any legal protection at all.
  • Keep only what you are prepared to have locked up for a long time on any single platform that uses your deposits.

What is still unknown

The final amount Mashinsky pays depends on conditions that have not played out yet, such as the federal forfeiture and whether he serves his full sentence. CoinDesk's report does not say when those conditions will be settled or how any money paid to New York will be used. For former customers, the bankruptcy process, not this settlement, remains the main route to getting funds back.

Sources

This safety brief was drafted by AI from the reports cited above and published automatically once our checks passed (figures matched to sources, no copied sentences). No person reviewed it before publication. It is general safety information, not advice on what to buy or sell.

← All posts

One plain-English lesson a week

Short, sourced and risk-first. No hype, no “signals”, no sales pitches.

↑↓ to moveEnter to open